Texas is the only state that lets most private employers skip workers’ compensation insurance entirely. Here’s what “non-subscriber” status means, the trade-offs involved, and what multi-state employers should watch for.
Texas’s Unusual Rule: Workers’ Comp Is Optional
Every other state requires most private employers to carry workers’ compensation insurance. Texas doesn’t. Under the Texas Workers’ Compensation Act, coverage is elective for private employers — a business can simply choose not to carry it. An employer that declines coverage is called a “non-subscriber.” To do this properly, the employer must file a notice of non-coverage with the Texas Department of Insurance, Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC), post notice of non-subscriber status at the workplace, and give new employees written notice at hire. (Note: Public employers and certain government construction contracts work differently and aren’t covered in this blog.)
What Happens If You Opt Out
Going without coverage doesn’t mean going without a plan. A non-subscriber pays no workers’ comp premiums, but it also loses the liability shield that comes with the state system — an injured employee can sue the company directly for negligence, with no cap on damages. Many non-subscribers respond by adopting a private occupational injury benefit plan (sometimes called an occupational accident plan), which pays benefits to injured workers on terms the employer sets, often structured to resemble an ERISA benefit plan. Done well, this can control costs and reduce litigation risk while still taking care of injured employees. Done poorly, it leaves the company exposed on two fronts at once.
The Trade-Off: Losing Your Common-Law Defenses
Texas law takes away three traditional defenses from non-subscribers facing a negligence suit: the employer can’t argue the employee’s own negligence contributed to the injury, can’t claim the employee assumed the risk of the job, and can’t point to a co-worker’s fault instead. That combination — full negligence exposure with none of the usual defenses — is why non-subscriber litigation tends to be higher-stakes than a typical workers’ comp claim, where benefits are fixed by schedule and fault mostly doesn’t matter.
Building a Compliant Non-Subscriber Program
Employers who go the non-subscriber route should have each of these in place:
- A timely notice of non-coverage filed with the Texas DWC, kept current as required
- Required workplace postings and written new-hire notices
- A carefully drafted written occupational injury benefit plan, with clear claims procedures
- Strong safety programs and disciplined incident investigation and documentation, since the loss of common-law defenses raises the stakes of every injury
- Adequate excess or umbrella coverage for a catastrophic claim
- Supervisor training on documentation, and on avoiding anything that could look like retaliation against an injured employee, which carries its own separate liability
The Multi-State Wrinkle
Non-subscriber status is a Texas-specific choice. It doesn’t travel. Employers with workers in other states need to separately confirm each state’s own workers’ compensation rules — most states mandate coverage, some allow narrow exemptions, and the thresholds (employee count, industry, payroll) differ from state to state and change over time. A program designed around Texas’s opt-out rule, applied without adjustment to employees elsewhere, can leave a multi-state employer uninsured where coverage was actually required — the worst of both outcomes.
When to Call a Lawyer
Talk to counsel before electing non-subscriber status in the first place, before adopting or updating an occupational injury benefit plan, before expanding a non-subscriber program into a new state, and immediately after any workplace injury where no coverage is in place. The cost-benefit analysis is specific to your workforce, your industry’s injury risk, and your footprint outside Texas — it isn’t a one-size-fits-all decision.
Simon | Paschal PLLC advises Texas employers on workers’ compensation elections, occupational injury benefit plans, and multi-state compliance. Contact us before you decide whether non-subscriber status is right for your business.